The 50% rule is the standard test. If a single repair costs more than 50% of the cost of a new equivalent unit, get a replacement quote alongside the repair estimate before you commit. In the worked example the $914 repair is 20% of a $4,500 replacement, so repair is clearly right.
The rule has two exceptions. If the unit is old and has a history of repeat repairs, replace it even when one repair passes the test, because the next repair is already coming. And if the fryer is the only one on the line, speed matters more than the rule, because a closed fry station forfeits a large share of the menu while you wait for a replacement. A new floor fryer costs $1,500 to $6,000, so the replace threshold usually sits at $750 to $3,000, and a gas valve job near that line deserves a hard look at replacement. Our commercial dishwasher repair cost calculator prices the same repair-or-replace choice for the dish machine.
Downtime is the cost the calculator cannot see. A fryer down on a Friday night costs more in lost sales than the repair itself, so a same-day repair at a fair price usually beats a cheaper repair that takes three days.